2023 Toyota Tundra Safety Report

The 2023 Toyota Tundra presents a mixed safety picture. While it boasts excellent crash test performance with a 5-star overall NHTSA rating, including 5 stars for frontal and side impacts, and a 4-star rollover rating, it is plagued by a significant number of complaints and recalls, particularly concerning the engine and power train. With 332 total complaints, 6 crashes, 5 fires, and 2 injuries reported, there are clear areas of concern outside of direct crashworthiness. A major pattern in the complaint data revolves around engine and power train issues, accounting for a substantial portion of the 55 'ENGINE' and 23 'POWER TRAIN' complaints. Many owners report 'hesitation' or 'throttle lag' from a stop, and more critically, 'loss of drive power' or 'engine shutting off' while driving, which directly aligns with multiple engine-related recalls. Several complaints detail metal fragments in engine oil or complete engine lock-up, indicating severe mechanical failures. The recall history is extensive, with 13 recalls, many of which address critical safety defects such as 'loss of drive power' due to manufacturing debris in the V35A engine, 'unexpected vehicle movement' from the automatic transmission, and 'fuel leaks' due to chafing fuel lines, all increasing the risk of a crash or fire. Beyond the engine, other notable recalls include issues with the rearview image not displaying, reverse light failure, and incorrect load carrying capacity labels, all of which can increase crash risk. The high number of complaints (332) for a relatively new model year, coupled with the severity of the issues addressed by 13 recalls, suggests that while the Tundra performs well in controlled crash tests, its real-world reliability and freedom from critical mechanical failures are significant concerns. The delay in recall part availability, as noted in several complaints, further exacerbates the safety risk for owners.

Our recommendation: Given the excellent crash test ratings but numerous critical engine and power train recalls, potential buyers should proceed with caution, thoroughly check for completed recall repairs, and consider an extended warranty.