2019 Bmw X5 Safety Report

The 2019 BMW X5 presents a mixed safety picture, with strong crash test performance but a notable number of consumer complaints and recalls. NHTSA awarded the vehicle an overall 4-star safety rating, including 4 stars for frontal crash, 5 stars for side crash, and 4 stars for rollover, indicating good occupant protection in various collision scenarios. However, the vehicle has accumulated 158 total complaints, with 4 reported crashes and 1 fire, though no injuries or deaths have been reported. A significant concern is the high number of recalls, totaling 13, which address a wide range of issues from critical safety components like airbags and brakes to potential fire hazards. Common complaint patterns revolve heavily around the ELECTRICAL SYSTEM (26 complaints) and ENGINE (18 complaints). Specific issues frequently cited in complaints include premature oil pump failure, often linked to internal plastic components, leading to low oil pressure warnings and potential engine damage. Several complaints also detail starter motor overheating, which is directly addressed by two recalls, highlighting a fire risk. Other recurring problems include issues with the infotainment/iDrive system going black, transfer case juddering, and leaks from the 'shark fin' antenna leading to electrical malfunctions. The extensive recall history underscores several design or manufacturing flaws. Two recalls specifically target the ELECTRICAL SYSTEM:STARTER ASSEMBLY due to overheating and fire risk. Other significant recalls include VISIBILITY:SUN/MOON ROOF ASSEMBLY for unexpected closing, AIR BAGS:FRONTAL for potential non-deployment, BACK OVER PREVENTION: SENSING SYSTEM: CAMERA for rearview image issues, SERVICE BRAKES, HYDRAULIC for reduced braking assistance, and STEERING for a loose column shaft bearing plate affecting control. The presence of recalls for fuel pump leaks and insufficiently tightened wheel bolts further emphasizes the breadth of safety-related concerns that BMW has had to address for this model year. While crash test ratings are generally good, the volume and nature of complaints and recalls suggest potential reliability and safety issues that buyers should be aware of.

Our recommendation: While the 2019 BMW X5 offers good crash protection, its extensive recall history and numerous complaints, particularly concerning engine oil pump failures and electrical issues, warrant caution. Prospective buyers should ensure all 13 recalls have been completed and factor in potential repair costs for known common problems.