2016 Kia Soul Safety Report

The 2016 Kia Soul presents a mixed safety picture. While it achieved excellent crash test ratings from NHTSA, scoring 5 stars overall, 5 stars for frontal and side impacts, and 4 stars for rollover, its real-world reliability and potential for catastrophic mechanical failures are concerning. With 779 total complaints, including 29 crashes, 32 fires, and 23 injuries, there's a significant pattern of serious issues. The most prominent concern revolves around the engine, accounting for 328 complaints, often leading to sudden power loss, stalling, and even engine fires. This is directly linked to a major recall concerning 1.6L GDI engines where high exhaust gas temperatures can damage the catalytic converter, leading to piston damage, engine stall, and potential engine block puncture. Even vehicles with 2.0L engines, not covered by this specific recall, show similar symptoms in complaints. Beyond the engine, a second recall addresses a steering issue where the pinion plug may allow the pinion gear to separate, resulting in a complete loss of steering. Although only 14 complaints specifically mention 'STEERING', the severity of this defect is extremely high. Other recurring issues include transmission problems, often manifesting as rough shifting, loss of acceleration, or complete failure, and less frequently, electrical shutdowns when adjusting the steering wheel tilt, and spontaneous shattering of the sunroof or rear windshield. The high number of engine-related complaints and the nature of the recalls indicate significant design or manufacturing flaws that can compromise vehicle control and occupant safety. Overall, while the 2016 Kia Soul performs well in controlled crash tests, its long-term operational safety is undermined by widespread engine failures, a critical steering defect, and other significant mechanical and electrical problems. The high incidence of engine stalls and power loss, as detailed in numerous complaints, poses a substantial risk of crashes, particularly in high-traffic or highway conditions. The 32 reported fires further underscore the severity of these mechanical issues, making the vehicle's real-world safety profile considerably lower than its crash test scores might suggest.

Our recommendation: Given the high incidence of severe engine failures, a critical steering recall, and other significant mechanical issues, exercise extreme caution. Prioritize a thorough pre-purchase inspection by an independent mechanic, specifically checking for engine health, recall completion, and steering system integrity.