2016 Mazda Mx-5 Safety Report

The 2016 Mazda MX-5 presents a mixed safety picture, with a relatively low number of total complaints (33) but significant concerns raised by recall history and specific complaint patterns. While NHTSA has not provided official crash test ratings for this model, three recalls address critical safety systems: airbags, structural integrity, and power train control. The 'AIR BAGS: AIR BAG/RESTRAINT CONTROL MODULE:SOFTWARE' recall (2016-2023 MX-5 Miata) indicates a risk of excessive force deployment, increasing injury risk. This is particularly concerning given a complaint detailing a severe rollover accident where no airbags deployed, resulting in serious injuries. The 'POWER TRAIN:AUTOMATIC TRANSMISSION:CONTROL MODULE (TCM/PCM/TECM)' recall for automatic transmissions (2016-2019 MX-5) highlights a risk of abrupt downshifts and loss of control, which aligns with multiple complaints about manual transmission failures, including locking up and difficulty shifting. Furthermore, the 'STRUCTURE:FRAME AND MEMBERS:UNDERBODY SHIELDS' recall for the 2016 model year addresses potential detachment of underbody parts, posing a road hazard. Common complaint patterns, even with the low overall count, point to significant issues. 'POWER TRAIN' is the most reported component with 10 complaints, many detailing manual transmission failures at relatively low mileages (e.g., 59,000 miles, 41,118 miles), including instances of locking up, difficulty shifting, and gear whine. 'AIR BAGS' account for 5 complaints, with several owners reporting non-deployment in crashes or delays in recall part availability. 'STRUCTURE' also has 4 complaints, including issues like windshield trim detaching and the convertible top liner obscuring the rear window. These patterns suggest that while the vehicle may not have a high volume of issues, the problems that do occur can be severe and directly impact safety. In summary, the 2016 Mazda MX-5's safety is primarily impacted by critical recalls concerning airbag deployment, transmission control, and structural integrity. The absence of NHTSA crash test ratings makes a full assessment challenging, but the existing complaint data, particularly regarding power train failures and airbag non-deployment, indicates areas of significant concern. Buyers should be aware of these specific issues and ensure all recalls have been addressed.

Our recommendation: Given the critical safety recalls and recurring complaints about transmission failures and airbag issues, thoroughly verify all recalls have been addressed and inspect the transmission and airbag system before purchasing a 2016 Mazda MX-5.