2019 Toyota Sienna Safety Report

The 2019 Toyota Sienna presents a mixed safety picture, with strong crash test performance but a notable number of recalls and concerning complaint patterns. It achieved an excellent 5-star overall safety rating from NHTSA, with 5 stars for side impact and 4 stars for frontal and rollover tests, indicating robust occupant protection in typical crash scenarios. However, the vehicle has been subject to 7 recalls, which is a significant number for a single model year. Two of these recalls specifically address fuel pump failures (NHTSA Campaign Numbers 20V012000 and 20V682000), which can lead to engine stalling and increased crash risk. Another critical recall (NHTSA Campaign Number 20V370000) involves potentially fractured steering shaft extensions in modified vehicles, posing a direct threat of loss of steering control. NHTSA complaint data, totaling 43 complaints with 2 crashes and 4 injuries, reveals several recurring issues. A prominent concern is related to the power train, specifically the transmission. Multiple complaints describe 'whining noise upon acceleration,' 'transmission failure,' and 'lurching forward on its own,' with some owners reporting full transmission replacements at relatively low mileages (e.g., 138k miles, or even earlier). This aligns with the 'POWER TRAIN' component being among the top reported issues. Another area of concern is the fuel system, with several complaints directly referencing the fuel pump recall and continued hesitation or stalling even after recall repairs, indicating persistent issues despite manufacturer intervention. Beyond the major mechanical issues, there are also complaints regarding the automatic sliding doors malfunctioning, sometimes closing with excessive force or trapping occupants, leading to injuries. Airbag deployment issues are also noted, including unintended deployment and non-deployment in a crash, which is particularly concerning given a recall (NHTSA Campaign Number 19V670000) specifically for incorrect welds affecting airbag sensor readings. While the Sienna's crash test ratings are high, the volume and nature of the complaints and recalls suggest that owners may encounter significant reliability and safety-related problems, particularly with the transmission and fuel system, and potentially with modified vehicles' steering and braking components.

Our recommendation: While the 2019 Toyota Sienna boasts high crash test ratings, potential buyers should be aware of the numerous recalls and recurring complaints, particularly concerning the transmission and fuel pump. Thoroughly check service history for recall compliance and transmission issues before purchase.