2017 Toyota Tundra Safety Report

The 2017 Toyota Tundra presents a mixed safety picture, with strong crash test performance but several concerning mechanical and electrical issues highlighted by consumer complaints and recalls. NHTSA awarded the vehicle an overall 4-star safety rating, including 4 stars for frontal crash, 5 stars for side crash, and 3 stars for rollover. This indicates good occupant protection in most collision types, though rollover risk is average. However, the vehicle has accumulated 76 total complaints, with 2 crashes, 0 fires, and 1 injury reported, suggesting some real-world safety incidents. A significant concern is the recall history, with 6 recalls issued. Two recalls specifically address the power steering gear assembly, warning of potential oil leaks leading to a sudden loss of power steering assist and increased crash risk. This aligns with several complaints detailing power steering rack and pinion failures, leaks, and clunking noises. Other recalls cover critical safety components such as rear split bench seat leg brackets (increasing injury risk in a crash), incorrect load information labels (leading to overloading and crash risk), and defective lug nuts on aftermarket wheels (causing wheel separation and crash risk). A recall also addresses resin rear step bumper issues, which could lead to injury if a portion breaks away. Complaint patterns reveal recurring problems with the FUEL/PROPULSION SYSTEM (11 complaints) and ELECTRICAL SYSTEM, EXTERIOR LIGHTING (11 complaints). Many fuel system complaints describe long cranking, difficulty starting, and fuel pump failures, with some owners noting similarities to issues covered by recalls for other model years. Electrical system complaints frequently mention headlights going out randomly, especially when using turn signals, posing a severe visibility hazard at night. The integrated trailer brake controller is also a common complaint, with multiple reports of insufficient braking power, creating a significant towing safety risk. While crash test ratings are generally good, the prevalence of steering, fuel system, and lighting issues, coupled with multiple recalls, suggests potential reliability and safety vulnerabilities that prospective buyers should be aware of.

Our recommendation: While the 2017 Tundra has solid crash test ratings, be aware of recurring issues with power steering, fuel pump failures, and electrical lighting problems, along with 6 recalls. Thoroughly inspect the power steering system and inquire about fuel pump service history before purchasing.