2017 Bmw X1 Safety Report
2017 BMW X1: Significant powertrain and gear selector complaints, two safety recalls, and no NHTSA crash test ratings.
AI Safety Analysis for the 2017 Bmw X1
Reliability Score
The 2017 Bmw X1 receives a reliability score of 45 out of 100 based on analysis of NHTSA complaint data, recall history, crash reports, and safety ratings. This indicates average reliability — some notable concerns exist that prospective buyers should be aware of.
Known Issues for the 2017 Bmw X1
The following issues have been identified from NHTSA complaint data and owner reports for the 2017 Bmw X1:
| Issue | Severity | Frequency | Typical Mileage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gear Selector Torsion Spring Failure Faulty gear selector torsion spring leads to 'secure vehicle against rolling' warnings, indicating the vehicle may not recognize it's in park, despite being mechanically engaged. This is a widely reported issue, with some owners noting it's a known problem shared with MINI models. |
Medium | Common | unknown miles |
| Engine Stalling/Rough Idle Vehicles experience rough idle at start and often stall after being placed in gear or while driving, sometimes after warming up. This can lead to loss of motive power. |
Medium | Occasional | unknown miles |
| Drivetrain Malfunction Error Sudden display of 'drivetrain malfunction' error, sometimes without apparent cause, indicating potential issues with the vehicle's powertrain system. |
Medium | Occasional | unknown miles |
| Engine Overheating/Coolant Leaks Reports of engine overheating, often linked to water pump failure or oil filter housing coolant leaks, leading to significant repair costs and potential engine damage. |
High | Occasional | unknown miles |
| B-Pillar Impact Absorption (Recall) Recall issued for insufficient B-pillar impact absorption in a crash, increasing the risk of injury to occupants. |
High | Rare | N/A miles |
| Front Seat Belt Retractor (Recall) Recall for front seat belt Emergency Locking Retractor (ELR) activating prematurely during heavy braking, potentially affecting occupant positioning in a crash. |
Medium | Rare | N/A miles |
Common Problems Reported by Owners
Based on NHTSA complaint data, the following components account for the majority of reported issues with the 2017 Bmw X1:
Frequent complaints related to the transmission, gear selector (specifically the 'secure vehicle against rolling' warning), and general drivetrain malfunctions.
A significant number of complaints categorized as 'unknown or other' often relate to general vehicle warnings, sensor issues, or problems not fitting specific component categories.
Complaints and a recall related to the body structure, specifically the B-pillar's crash absorption capabilities.
Issues potentially related to sensors, warning lights, and general electrical malfunctions.
Some reports concerning braking system performance, though less frequent than powertrain issues.
Complaints including engine stalling, overheating, and issues with engine mounts or coolant systems.
Frequently Asked Questions About the 2017 Bmw X1
Is the 2017 BMW X1 safe?
Based on NHTSA data, the 2017 BMW X1 has 154 total complaints, including 3 crashes and 10 injuries. While specific NHTSA crash test ratings are unavailable, there are two safety recalls concerning the B-pillar's crash absorption and front seat belt retractors. A significant number of owner complaints relate to powertrain issues, particularly the gear selector and engine performance, which could pose safety concerns like unexpected stalling or rolling warnings.
What are common problems with the 2017 BMW X1?
The most reported issues for the 2017 BMW X1 are related to the POWER TRAIN (36 complaints), often involving the 'secure vehicle against rolling' warning due to a faulty gear selector torsion spring, engine stalling, and drivetrain malfunctions. Other common problems include issues categorized as UNKNOWN OR OTHER (31 complaints), and concerns with the STRUCTURE (13 complaints) and ELECTRICAL SYSTEM (9 complaints).
Are there any recalls for the 2017 BMW X1?
Yes, the 2017 BMW X1 has two recalls. One recall (NHTSA ID: 19V072000) addresses the STRUCTURE:BODY:ROOF AND PILLARS, where the B-pillar may not absorb sufficient impact in a crash, increasing injury risk. The second recall (NHTSA ID: 17V082000) is for SEAT BELTS:FRONT:RETRACTOR, where the Emergency Locking Retractor may activate prematurely during heavy braking.
What does 'secure vehicle against rolling' mean for the 2017 BMW X1?
The 'secure vehicle against rolling' warning in the 2017 BMW X1 is a common issue, frequently linked to a faulty gear selector torsion spring. This warning indicates that the vehicle's system may not correctly recognize that the car is in park, even if it is mechanically. While often described as a faulty wire or spring, it prompts users to engage the parking brake and consult a service center, raising concerns about the vehicle's ability to remain stationary.
How reliable is the 2017 BMW X1?
Based on 154 NHTSA complaints, with a high concentration in powertrain and 'unknown' categories, and known issues like the gear selector failure and engine problems, the 2017 BMW X1 shows signs of below-average reliability, particularly concerning its transmission and engine components. The presence of two recalls also points to manufacturing or design flaws.
Buyer Advice
Our recommendation: Prospective buyers of a 2017 BMW X1 should be aware of significant powertrain and gear selector issues, and factor in potential repair costs for these common problems. Thorough pre-purchase inspection, especially of the transmission and engine, is highly recommended, and verify if recall repairs have been completed.
NHTSA Data Summary for 2017 Bmw X1
This safety report is based on a comprehensive analysis of data from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) for the 2017 Bmw X1. The data includes 154 consumer complaints filed by vehicle owners, 2 manufacturer-initiated safety recalls, 3 reported crashes, 10 reported injuries, and safety rating assessments associated with this vehicle.
All data presented in this report is sourced from public NHTSA databases. Our AI analysis identifies patterns across complaint narratives, correlates them with recall history, and produces the safety assessment above. This analysis is updated as new complaints and recalls are filed with the NHTSA.
Consumers are encouraged to report vehicle safety problems to the NHTSA at nhtsa.gov. If your vehicle is subject to a recall, contact your dealer to schedule the free repair.